Alas, Poor Darwin: Arguments Against Evolutionary Psychology by Hilary Rose, Steven Rose

By Hilary Rose, Steven Rose

This day, genes are known as upon to give an explanation for virtually each element of our lives, from social inequalities to overall healthiness, sexual choice and illegal activity. in line with Darwin's thought of evolution and traditional choice, Evolutionary Psychology with its declare that 'it's all in our genes' has develop into the preferred medical thought of the overdue twentieth century. Books akin to Richard Dawkins's The egocentric Gene, Edward O.Wilson's Consilience and Steven Pinker's The Language intuition became bestsellers and body the general public debate on human lifestyles and improvement: we will see their effect once we open a Sunday newspaper. lately, despite the fact that, many biologists and social scientists have all started to contest this new organic determinism and proven that Evolutionary Psychology rests on shaky empirical proof, wrong premises and unexamined political presuppositions. during this provocative and ground-breaking booklet, Hilary and Steven Rose have accumulated jointly the main eminent and outspoken critics of this stylish ideology, starting from Stephen Jay Gould and Patrick Bateson to Mary Midgley, Tim Ingold and Annette Karmiloff-Smith. What emerges is a brand new standpoint on human improvement which recognizes the complexity of existence via putting at its centre the dwelling organism instead of the gene.

Show description

Read or Download Alas, Poor Darwin: Arguments Against Evolutionary Psychology PDF

Best biology & life sciences books

Biology for a Changing World

From the groundbreaking partnership of W. H. Freeman and Scientific American comes this distinct creation to the technological know-how of biology and its impression at the method we are living. In Biology for a altering global, skilled educators and a technology journalist discover the center rules of biology via a chain of chapters written and illustrated within the form of a systematic American article.

Extra resources for Alas, Poor Darwin: Arguments Against Evolutionary Psychology

Sample text

Convinced that evolutionary explanations should prevail over all other beliefs, he seeks conversions. Missionaries, inspired by their revelations, often place limited value on empirical evidence. Holistic narratives become more important than detailed logical structure, for theories follow from a kind of revealed truth. Evolutionary psychologists admit there is a paucity of examples for behavioural genetics. And they acknowledge the great difficulty in showing the empirical basis of epigenetic rules – the hereditary regularities in the development process – as applied to human behaviour.

33 Why support job training, welfare or childcare programmes when those targeted are biologically incapable of benefiting from the effort? Theories about the evolutionary basis of status distinctions are a way to explain persistent poverty and social inequalities. Attaining status, so the argument goes, enables people to attract mates and to pass on their genes. 34 Similarly, J. Philippe Rushton presents a theory of racial differences in brain and genital size, which he claims are based on evolutionary adaptations.

January 2000 Notes and References 1 Other European countries, notably France, have been less overwhelmed by Darwinian evolutionary theory. 2 Jonathan Weiner, The Beak of the Finch (London, Vintage, 1994). 3 Randy Thornhill and Craig Palmer, A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion (Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, 2000), p. 179. 4 It is interesting in this context that the theme of the Expo 2000 festival in Hanover in Germany is the need for the twenty-first century to clear up the scientific and technological mess left by the twentieth.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.93 of 5 – based on 11 votes